Based on the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court’s recent ruling, car owners in Massachusetts who want to recover diminished value compensation after accident repairs must now obtain a final judgment against the at-fault driver instead of seeking payment from their insurer. This effectively forces claimants into litigation rather than allowing them to recover diminished value directly through an insurance claim.
This process creates additional legal hurdles for car owners, as they must file a lawsuit, present evidence of diminished value, and win a judgment. The decision stems from changes in the 2016 Massachusetts Standard Auto Insurance Policy, which explicitly excludes compensation for diminished value unless required by law. In contrast, under the 2008 policy, diminished value compensation was recoverable.
As a result, Massachusetts vehicle owners may face increased costs and delays when trying to recover financial losses caused by a vehicle’s reduced market value after repairs.
This ruling places a significant burden on the Massachusetts court system, particularly in small claims courts – where there is no ceiling on how much can be recovered in auto-related lawsuits – as more car owners are forced to litigate their diminished value claims rather than resolving them through insurance claims.
1. Increase in Small Claims Filings – This means a surge in filings from vehicle owners seeking compensation, potentially overwhelming small claims courts.
2. Backlog in Small Claims Courts – This could lead to an increase in civil lawsuits, adding to already existing court backlogs.
3. Delays in Case Resolutions – More cases mean longer wait times for hearings and judgments, delaying justice for car owners seeking compensation. The process of proving diminished value often requires expert testimony, further complicating cases.
4. Higher Litigation Costs – Vehicle owners now must bear the financial burden of court fees, legal consultation (optional), and expert appraisers to prove their claims—expenses they wouldn’t have incurred if insurance companies were required to pay diminished value directly.
5. More Appeals and Legal Challenges – The ruling may lead to appeals and legal disputes, as claimants challenge insurers and seek precedents that could reverse or refine this decision in future cases.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court’s decision shifts the responsibility from insurers to individual claimants, effectively forcing more cases into the state’s already burdened court system. This could result in delays, increased costs, and legal complications (providing a poorly-prepared diminished value report could result in an adverse judgement) for both car owners and the judicial system.
Although this seems like a blow to the state’s consumers, it may be a blessing in disguise. Dealing with insurance companies is a tedious, time-consuming and often frustrating experience. Now, a simple lawsuit and the matter gets quickly adjudicated by a magistrate in your county. And, in Massachusetts, there is no limit as to how much you can sue for in small claims court as long as a motor vehicle was involved. So, if your car has lost tens of thousands of dollars in value, small claims court is the venue in which you can recover it. At massachusettsdiminishedvalue.com you will obtain the most compelling proof of your car’s diminished value. Our reports are superior evidence on which Massachusetts car owners can rely. Please call us at 772-359-4300 for more information.
Click on the payment button above to pay by Credit Card or Paypal. The fee for an Automobile Diminished Value Report is
$275.00. You may also make your Credit Card Payment by telephone, call 772-359-4300.
Service in Amherst, Arlington, Attleboro, Barnstable, Beverly, Billerica, Boston, Braintree, Bridgewater, Brockton, Cambridge, Chicopee, Fall River, Framingham, Haverhill, Lawrence, Lowell, Lynn, Malden, Medford, Methuen, New Bedford, Newton, Peabody, Pittsfield, Quincy, Revere, Salem, Somerville, Springfield, Taunton, Waltham, Weymouth, Worcester and throughout Massachusetts
Barnstable, Berkshire, Bristol, Dukes, Essex, Franklin, Hampden, Hampshire, Middlesex, Nantucket, Norfolk, Plymouth, Suffolk and Worcester Counties
READ MORE ARTICLES…